| Men |
| NAME | Year | Weapon | Hometown/High School |
| Greg Allen | SO | Saber | Homewood, Ill./Homewood Flossmoor |
| Ben Brown | SO | Epee | Cleveland, Ohio/Lutheran High School West |
| Liran Gross | JR | Foil | Beer-Sheva, Israel |
| Jason Heiss | SR | Sabre | Willowick, Ohio/Eastlake North |
| Matt Itomlenskis | JR | Epee | Cleveland, Ohio/Brush |
| John Marshall | SO | Epee | Lakewood, Ohio/Lakewood |
| Chris McGuire | JR | Foil | Cleveland, Ohio/John F. Kennedy |
| Stephen Montgomery | JR | Foil | Burlington, N.J./Burlington |
| Zackary Morell | JR | Epee | Brook Park, Ohio/Midpark |
| James Pitchford | SO | Epee | Lakewood, Ohio/Lakewood |
| Bryan Ritchey | FR | Foil | Cleveland Heights, Ohio/Cleveland Heights |
| Andy Snell | SR | Epee | Clarks Green, Pa./Abington Heights |
| Bryan Twitchell | FR | Saber | Toledo, Ohio/Roy C. Start |
 |
| Women |
| NAME | Year | Weapon | Hometown/High School |
| Laura Duval | FR | Epee | Algonquin, Ill./Marion Central Catholic |
| Elyra Gonzalez | FR | Foil | |
| Stephanie Lee | FR | Foil | Richfield, Ohio/Revere |
| Heather Nguyen | SR | Foil | Cleveland, Ohio/Northside (Ga.) |
| Danielle Shepherd | SR | Saber | Cleveland, Ohio/John Marshall |
| Brooke Snyder | JR | Epee | Mishawaka, Ind./Concord |
| Courtney Zemkosky | SR | Epee | New Middletown, Ohio/Springfield Local |
|
